Intereting Posts

Number of points on an elliptic curve over $ \mathbb{F}_{q} $.
Calculation of limit without stirling approximation
Solving the functional equation $f(xy)=f(f(x)+f(y))$
What might I use to show that an entire function with positive real parts is constant?
Is it true that $ U \oplus W_1 = U \oplus W_2 \implies W_1 = W_2 $?
Product of $5$ consecutive integers cannot be perfect square
chameleon puzzle- modified one
Proving $\kappa^{\lambda} = |\{X: X \subseteq \kappa, |X|=\lambda\}|$
Produce an explicit bijection between rationals and naturals?
Why is this inclusion of dual of Banach spaces wrong?
A “prime-mapping” polynomial
For every $\epsilon >0$ , if $a+\epsilon >b$ , can we conclude $a>b$?
Correct definition of bilinear(multilinear) maps over noncommutative rings
Can the graph of $x^x$ have a real-valued plot below zero?
Dirichlet Series and Average Values of Certain Arithmetic Functions

variable: A symbol used to represent one or more numbers.

High school students are justifiably confused by the two distinct concepts:

- a variable as something that “varies” in an

expression, such as the h in the expression $4.50\cdot h$;

and - an unknown quantity that is a “specific unknown” in an

equation

The definition of a variable as being a symbol used to

represent both of these cases explicitly states this

as: “a symbol used to represent one or more numbers.”

Where the “one number” case is the “specific unknown” in a simple

equation, such as $18.00=4.50\cdot h\;$ where the $h$ can only

represent the one number $4$ to turn the open sentence into

a true statement.

- Effect of adding a constant to both Numerator and Denominator
- Calculus book recommendations (for complete beginner)
- System of $24$ variables
- Cubic trig equation
- Integer values of $\frac{x}{y}+\frac{y}{z}+\frac{z}{x}$?
- Show that there exist only $n$ solutions

The more than one number case being the letter h standing

for values in a table such as: $1, 2, 3,\>$ or $4$ being

substituted into an equation to form a pattern such as

$C=4.50\cdot h$, the definition of a variable now being

interpreted as a symbol, h, used to represent one number

when that number is substituted in for it and a symbol

used to represent more than one number when other numbers

are substituted in for it. Thus generating a table of

values of $C$ such as: $4.50, 9.00, 13.50,\>$ and $18.00$.

Another example, the variable, say x, in the quadratic equation represents a parabola when it “varies” over a given domain. But the variable in the equation $0=x^2+2x+1$ is “an unknown quantity. It does not vary.” Thus, in this case the vari-able has lost its ability to “vary.” Yet in both situations they are referred to as a variable, and this duality is embodied in the definition of a variable as “a symbol used to represent one or more numbers.” Could the motivation behind this definition be such that we don’t have to make the distinction between an “unknown specific quantity” and a “varying” quantity?

Does anyone agree that the above argument has been logically developed or

is there some flaw in my reasoning? Thank you.

a symbol used to represent one or more numbers

See here

- A simple proof that $\bigl(1+\frac1n\bigr)^n\leq3-\frac1n$?
- How to find the sum of the sequence $\frac{1}{1+1^2+1^4} +\frac{2}{1+2^2+2^4} +\frac{3}{1+3^2+3^4}+…$
- Proportional to 2 Separate Variables vs. Proportional to Product of 2 Variables
- Prove that the expression is a perfect square
- How can I prove the formula for calculating successive entries in a given row of Pascal's triangle?
- Solve $\epsilon x^3-x+1=0$
- how can one solve for $x$, $x =\sqrt{2+\sqrt{2+\sqrt{2\cdots }}}$
- Why does basic algebra provide one value for $x$ when there should be two?
- Educational Math Software
- Sum of first n natural numbers proof

The duality embodied in the definition of a variable as:

“A symbol used to represent one or more numbers.”

Is such that we don’t have to make the distinction between an “unknown specific quantity” and a “varying” quantity.

I don’t like the word “variable” in math. When we’re solving an equation, $x$ is nothing more than the name of a number whose value we do not yet know, $x$ is not in any sense “variable”. It’s not as if the value of $x$ can change.

And if we are defining a function $f$, we might say something like, if $x$ is a number, then $f(x) = x^2 + 7$ . Even here $x$ is not “variable”. We are just saying that if $x$ is a (specific) number, then $f(x)$ is the number $x^2 + 7$.

Now, in computer programming, you have variables whose value can actually change. That’s different.

There probably should be a strict distinction made between variables and constants. For example in a quadratic equation $f(x) = Ax^2+Bx+C,$ the letters $A,B$, and $C$ are constants in the sense that they are standing in for specific values. The variable in the equation (rather the independent variable) is $x$. The dependent variable is $y=f(x)$. This equation, which represents a parabola, is different than $0 =Ax^2+Bx+C$. Here $A$, $B$, and $C$ still represent constants, but $x$ is an unknown quantity. It does not vary. Still the nature of the solution set to that equation varies if the values of the constants $A$, $B$, and $C$ vary.

To say that the “constants *may* vary” does sound oxymoronic and counter-intuitive. I am sure that we all are guilty of having uttered such a sentence. One point of algebraic expressions is that any of the letters may be considered as a variable. Once specific values are chosen, the express becomes more definite. Indeed, all algebraic laws (at the level of high school mathematics) can be considered to be universal truths about the expression for any specific values of the variables.

I am sure that there are other real-word instances of such ambiguity in the language.

It’s a philosophical question. So far I have never met a mathematically hard definition of the notion of “variable”, as it is used in analysis (“free” and “bound” variables in logic are another matter). Here are some musings on the theme:

Given any set $S$ and any symbol or letter $x$ one can declare $x$ as a *variable with values in* $S$. In a typical mathematical discourse there are various sets $S_i$ around and associated variables $x_{i,k}$ taking values in $S_i$. Furthermore one considers equations (or relations) among the $x_{i,k}$ which make the values of some of them dependent on the values of others, or force some of the $x_{i,k}$ to assume values in a particular subset of $S_i$, or create some other “dependency” among the $x_{i,k}$. There may also be a ranking among the occurring $x_{i,k}$ where some of them are “less variable” than others. The former are called *parameters* of an instance of the considered problem, the later are called *variables* or *unknowns*, depending on the intended interpretation.

First expression has only one variable which is h and it is fixed.

Second expression has two variables which are h and C. Here h and C are depended from one another. values of h will be changed when values of C change or values of C will be changed when values of h change. That’s why h and C have so many values.

- Evaluating $\lim_{n\rightarrow\infty}x_{n+1}-x_n$
- Limit of $f(x+\sqrt x)-f(x)$ as $x \to\infty$ if $|f'(x)|\le 1/x$ for $x>1$
- Linear Code in Cryptography
- Calculating the total number of surjective functions
- Proof that $S_3$ isomorphic to $D_3$
- prove $x \mapsto x^2$ is continuous
- Is closure of convex subset of $X$ is again a convex subset of $X$?
- Example of dynamical system where: $NW(f) \not\subset \overline{R(f)}$
- Determinant of rank-one perturbation of a diagonal matrix
- The limit of $\sin(1/x)$ as $x\to 0$ does not exists
- Suppose $(s_n)$ converges and that $s_n \geq a$ for all but finitely many terms, show $\lim s_n \geq a$
- Nets of Geodesic spheres
- Assigning values to divergent series
- How to correctly do a division using a slash?
- Differential operators confussion